Weathered Blackbutt 5mm Tranquility vinyl plank in a kitchen with a white island bench and timber dining chairs

Vinyl is the better pick where water is a risk or floor height is tight, because it is made of PVC all the way through and can be as thin as 2.5mm. Laminate suits bedrooms, living areas and hallways where you want a firmer floor that feels closer to timber, since it is built on a wood fibre core under a hard wear layer. On price they overlap: our published supply range is $25 to $45 per m2 for vinyl and $25 to $65 per m2 for laminate.

Below is a side by side table, then the differences that decide most jobs: water, feel and noise, floor height, the subfloor, wear and the rooms each one suits. Every product figure comes from the vinyl and laminate ranges we sell.

Laminate vs vinyl at a glance

Vinyl plank Laminate
Core Layers of PVC, some with fibreglass reinforcement High density fibreboard (HDF), which is compressed wood fibre
Top surface Clear PVC wear layer, 0.5mm on Tranquility and Olympus Neo Melamine wear layer graded by AC rating, AC4 on Forestbrook and Luxe Grain
Water NFD describes the Tranquility surface as waterproof Rated in hours: 36 on Luxe Grain 8mm, 72 on Luxe Grain 12mm
Thickness in our range 2.5mm to 5.3mm 8mm to 14mm
How it goes down Glued down, loose laid, or as the range specifies Floating, with click joints over an underlay
Underfoot Softer and quieter Firmer, closer to a timber floor
Supply price (our FAQ range) $25 to $45 per m2 $25 to $65 per m2

The table gives the headline. The sections below explain which row matters most in your home.

What each floor is made of

Both floors use a printed photo of timber under a clear protective layer. The difference sits underneath that photo.

Vinyl plank is plastic through its full depth. Our Tranquility range, for example, is a 5mm plank with a 0.5mm wear layer, fibreglass reinforcement and a built in acoustic backing. There is no wood in it at all.

Laminate is mostly wood. Forestbrook boards from Dunlop have an AC4 melamine wear layer and a decor layer over a melamine-infused HDF core, with a recycled-material backing underneath. That fibreboard core is what makes laminate stiff, and it is also the part that does not like water.

If you want the full detail on either one, our guides to what vinyl flooring is and what laminate flooring is go layer by layer.

Water: the biggest difference

A spill on vinyl sits on plastic. NFD describes the Tranquility surface as waterproof, so a knocked over glass or a leaking dishwasher hose will not swell the plank.

Laminate is sold as water resistant, and the rating is given in hours. It tells you how long water can sit on the surface before the board is at risk. Luxe Grain is a good example: the 8mm board is rated for 36 hours and the 12mm board for 72 hours.

Feature Blackbutt 12mm Luxe Grain laminate in an open kitchen with two woven bar stools at a white island

Seventy two hours covers most kitchen accidents, including a leak you only find the next morning. It does not cover a floor that gets wet every day.

Keep one thing in mind with vinyl, too. A waterproof plank does not make the room waterproof. Water that gets under the edges or through the joins can still reach the subfloor, so a bathroom or laundry is checked against the maker's requirements at the measure before anything is ordered.

Feel, warmth and noise

Vinyl has a little give, so it feels softer and quieter underfoot. Glued down vinyl such as Olympus Neo is bonded to the subfloor, which means there is no hollow click and no bounce when you walk on it.

Laminate floats on an underlay. That makes it firmer and closer to the feel of real boards, especially at 12mm or 14mm. Over a poor subfloor, though, a thin floating board can sound hollow.

Apartments add a rule of their own. Many strata schemes set an acoustic standard for hard floors, so check your by-laws before choosing either type. Tranquility has acoustic backing built in, and NFD's acoustic guide puts it at up to 6 stars (Ln,w 39) over a 200mm concrete slab with two layers of 13mm plasterboard below. NFD says those results are a guide only.

Floor height and the subfloor

Thickness decides how much the floor rises at doorways. Olympus Neo is 2.5mm, the thinnest floor we stock, so doors and kitchen kickboards usually stay as they are. Our laminate starts at 8mm and goes up to 14mm, which can mean trimming doors or adding a ramp where it meets tiles or carpet.

The trade off is the subfloor. Because vinyl is so thin, any ridge, old paint blob or join in the base can show through once light hits it from the side. A thicker laminate board bridges small hollows better.

Hallway subfloor during preparation, with old boards patched in blue compound before the new floor goes down

So a vinyl job often spends more time on preparation. Our regular installers check the subfloor at the free measure, and any levelling it needs is listed on the written quote.

Scratches, dents and wear

Both floors have tough surfaces when you buy a good grade. Look at the published ratings rather than the thickness.

  • Laminate is graded by AC rating. AC4 suits busy homes and light commercial use, and both Forestbrook and Luxe Grain are AC4.
  • Vinyl is graded by its wear layer and abrasion class. Olympus Neo has Group T abrasion, the top class for vinyl, and residual indentation of 0.03mm, so furniture legs do not leave permanent dents.
  • Slip ratings overlap. Luxe Grain, Tranquility and Olympus Neo are all rated P3.

Neither floor can be sanded back like timber. A deep gouge means replacing the damaged plank, which is easier on a floating or loose laid floor than on a glued one.

Which rooms suit which floor

Here is how we would split a typical Sydney home.

  • Kitchen: either works. Pick vinyl for peace of mind with water, or a laminate rated for 72 hours if you prefer the firmer feel.
  • Bathroom and laundry: vinyl, after the maker's wet area requirements are checked. Laminate is not a wet area floor.
  • Bedrooms, living rooms and hallways: laminate is a strong choice here, with an AC4 board for hallways.
  • Renovations over an existing floor: thin glue down vinyl, where height matters most.
  • Offices and shops: both. NFD lists Luxe Grain as Commercial Project Approved, and Olympus Neo carries a Commercial 33 rating.

Living room finished in a grey-brown timber-look plank floor running to a sliding glass door

Plenty of homes mix the two, with vinyl in the wet rooms and laminate through the living areas. If you do, plan the transition strips where the floors meet.

What they cost

Our FAQ page lists vinyl at $25 to $45 per m2 and hybrid and laminate together at $25 to $65 per m2. Treat those as supply prices for the flooring itself.

Installation is quoted separately after the measure. Vinyl can need more subfloor work, while laminate can need more trimming at doors, so the cheaper plank does not always give the cheaper job.

Where hybrid fits in

Hybrid sits between the two. It has a vinyl top layer over a rigid core and clicks together like laminate, so it handles water better than laminate and feels firmer than thin vinyl. We compare it with laminate in a separate guide, so we will leave it there.

Browse our vinyl flooring and laminate flooring ranges, or book a free measure and quote anywhere in Sydney.